Login

AMD vs. Nvidia AI: Taking the Fight to the Rack

Polkadotedge 2025-11-06 Total views: 13, Total comments: 0 amd

AMD's AI Gambit: Rack-Scale or Bust?

AMD is stepping into the AI infrastructure ring with its Helios rack-scale system, slated for a 2026 launch. The ambition is clear: directly challenge Nvidia's dominance. But ambition doesn't always translate to market share. The success of Helios hinges on a successful integration of next-gen GPUs (MI400 series) and CPUs (Venice), and that's where the real gamble lies.

Dr. Lisa Su, during the Q3 2025 earnings call, highlighted the progress in the datacenter, AI, and server businesses. Server CPU revenue hit an all-time high, propelled by the 5th Gen Epyc Turin processors, which accounted for nearly half of overall Epyc revenue. That’s good news, but the AI play is a different beast altogether.

AMD is touting Helios as a system that operates a rack full of accelerators as a single, large GPU, similar to Nvidia’s DGX GB200 NVL72. "Helios integrates our Instinct MI400 Series GPUs, Epyc Venice CPUs and Pensando NICs in a double-wide rack solution…and supports Meta's new open rack wide standard," Su stated. The involvement of the ZT Systems team (acquired last year) is also flagged as critical. But here’s where my skepticism kicks in.

The Devil's in the Deployment

The claim that "development of both our MI400 Series GPUs and Helios rack is progressing rapidly" needs closer scrutiny. "Rapidly" is a subjective term. What are the actual development milestones? What are the yields on the 2nm process from TSMC that will be used for the Venice CPUs (6th-gen Epyc)? These are the questions that matter.

Consider this: AMD's CFO, Jean Hu, was cagey about when the rack-scale push would impact the bottom line. "We're not guiding 2026, but our priority in datacenter GPU business is to really expand the top line revenue growth and the gross margin dollars," she said. That's CFO-speak for "we're not sure it'll make money right away." It’s a priority to grow revenue and grow margin dollars, not necessarily to become profitable, at least not immediately. There is a discrepancy between claiming rapid progress and being unable to project revenue impact.

AMD vs. Nvidia AI: Taking the Fight to the Rack

AMD also has an agreement with OpenAI. Analyst Timothy Arcuri (UBS Investment Bank) pointed out that OpenAI could represent half of AMD's datacenter GPU revenue in 2027-2028. Su brushed this aside, stating that AMD is dimensioning the supply chain to accommodate multiple customers at a similar scale. This sounds reassuring, but it introduces another risk: over-reliance on a single customer.

I've looked at hundreds of these filings, and this reliance on a single large client is unusual. What happens if OpenAI shifts its architectural preferences or develops its own silicon? AMD's datacenter GPU business would take a significant hit.

The CPU Silver Lining

Amidst the AI frenzy, AMD is seeing a pickup in CPU demand. "A number of our large hyperscale clients are now forecasting significant CPU build into 2026. And so from that standpoint, I think it's a positive demand environment, and it is because AI is requiring quite a bit of general-purpose compute," Su explained. This is a crucial point. AI isn't just about GPUs; it requires substantial CPU resources as well.

AMD's overall revenue grew 36% to $9.2 billion in Q3 2025. Datacenter revenue was up 22% to $4.3 billion, driven by MI350 series GPUs and server share gains. Client and gaming revenue surged 73% to $4 billion, with record PC processor sales. (The embedded portfolio saw an 8% decline, but AMD expects record design wins.) AMD forecasts Q4 2025 revenue of $9.6 billion (plus or minus $300 million), representing roughly 25% year-on-year growth.

The key takeaway? AMD's diversified business provides a buffer against the uncertainties of the AI infrastructure market. While Helios represents a high-stakes bet, AMD isn't solely dependent on its success. AMD taking AI fight to Nvidia with Helios rack-scale system

The Rack-Scale Hype Train Needs Brakes

The ambition is admirable, but the execution is what matters. AMD's Helios faces significant hurdles, including manufacturing yields, customer concentration, and the ever-shifting landscape of AI hardware. It's a moonshot, not a sure thing.

Don't miss